How To Fix J3229 - Position generation control different in position and costing rule

SAP Error Message - Details

• Message type: E = Error

• Message class: J3 - Dialog Messages for Data Pool Entry Transactions

• Message number: 229

• Message text: Position generation control different in position and costing rule

What causes this issue?

Costing rule '&V1&' and the position both have different controls for
position generation.

System Response

The financial object is inconsistent and cannot be saved.

How to fix this error?

Assign a costing rule to the financial object in the profitability
analysis part. The costing rule must have the same control for position
generation as the corresponding position.

Error message extract from SAP system. Copyright SAP SE.

Smart SAP Assistant

• What is the cause and solution for SAP error message J3229 - Position generation control different in position and costing rule ?

  The SAP error message J3229, which states "Position generation control different in position and costing rule," typically occurs in the context of SAP's Controlling (CO) module, particularly when dealing with internal orders, projects, or cost centers. This error indicates a mismatch between the position generation control settings in the position and the costing rule associated with it.
  Cause:
  The error arises due to discrepancies in the configuration settings for position generation control. Specifically, it can occur when:
  
  Inconsistent Settings: The position generation control settings in the position master data do not match those defined in the costing rule.
  Configuration Issues: There may be a misconfiguration in the controlling area or the settings for the specific order type or project type.
  Data Entry Errors: Incorrect data entry during the creation or modification of positions or costing rules can lead to this error.
  
  Solution:
  To resolve the J3229 error, you can follow these steps:
  
  
  Check Position Master Data:
  
  Navigate to the position master data in SAP and review the position generation control settings.
  Ensure that the settings are consistent with the costing rule.
  
  
  
  Review Costing Rule:
  
  Access the costing rule configuration and verify the position generation control settings.
  Make sure that they align with the settings in the position master data.
  
  
  
  Adjust Settings:
  
  If discrepancies are found, adjust the settings in either the position master data or the costing rule to ensure they match.
  You may need to consult with your SAP configuration team or refer to the relevant documentation for guidance on the correct settings.
  
  
  
  Test Changes:
  
  After making adjustments, test the changes by attempting to generate positions again to see if the error persists.
  
  
  
  Consult Documentation:
  
  Refer to SAP documentation or help resources for detailed information on position generation control and costing rules.
  
  
  
  Seek Support:
  
  If the issue persists after checking and adjusting the settings, consider reaching out to SAP support or your internal SAP support team for further assistance.
  
  
  
  Related Information:
  
  Transaction Codes: You may need to use transaction codes such as CJ20N (Project Builder), KO02 (Change Order), or KP26 (Change Plan Data) to access the relevant data.
  Configuration Path: The configuration for costing rules can typically be found under the following path in the SAP menu: 
  
  SPRO > Controlling > Cost Center Accounting > Master Data > Cost Center > Define Costing Sheet.
  
  
  Documentation: SAP Help Portal and SAP Notes can provide additional insights and troubleshooting steps related to this error.
  
  By following these steps, you should be able to identify and resolve the cause of the J3229 error in SAP.