How To Fix ICL584 - You can only create one benefit decision

SAP Error Message - Details

• Message type: E = Error

• Message class: ICL - FS-CM: Claims Management

• Message number: 584

• Message text: You can only create one benefit decision

Self-Explanatory Message

Since SAP believes that this specific error message is 'self-explanatory,' no more information has been given.The majority of messages in the SAP system have a message text, however this is frequently insufficient to comprehend or resolve the problem.

To make things easier, more detailed information is frequently added to describe the issue, how to fix it, and the necessary steps or configuration modifications.

Unfortunately, there isn't any extra information in this error notice.

What else can you do?

First, use our AnswerBot below to get a possible cause and solution (requires a premium subscription).

Also, review the in-depth Common Questions & Answers listed below; you could discover a solution there or be able to connect with others who have faced similar challenges.

You can also try searching the SAP support portal (support.sap.com) but you need a special user ID to access it. It is possible that an SAP support note exists that provides additional details about the mistake or even steps for fixing it.

Smart SAP Assistant

• What is the cause and solution for SAP error message ICL584 - You can only create one benefit decision ?

  The SAP error message ICL584, which states "You can only create one benefit decision," typically occurs in the context of the SAP Benefits Management module, particularly when dealing with benefit decisions for employees. This error indicates that the system has detected an attempt to create multiple benefit decisions for the same employee or benefit type, which is not allowed.
  Cause:
  
  Existing Benefit Decision: The most common cause of this error is that there is already an existing benefit decision for the employee in question. SAP restricts the creation of multiple benefit decisions to maintain data integrity and avoid conflicts.
  Incorrect Data Entry: There may be a mistake in the data entry process, such as selecting the wrong employee or benefit type.
  System Configuration: The system may be configured to allow only one benefit decision per employee for a specific benefit type, which is a standard practice in many organizations.
  
  Solution:
  
  
  Check Existing Benefit Decisions: 
  
  Navigate to the relevant transaction in SAP (e.g., transaction code HRBEN0001 or similar) to view existing benefit decisions for the employee.
  If a benefit decision already exists, you may need to modify or delete it before creating a new one.
  
  
  
  Review Employee and Benefit Type:
  
  Ensure that you are working with the correct employee and benefit type. Double-check the selection criteria to avoid any mix-ups.
  
  
  
  Modify Existing Decision:
  
  If the existing benefit decision needs to be updated, you can modify it instead of creating a new one. Use the appropriate transaction to make the necessary changes.
  
  
  
  Consult Documentation:
  
  Review the SAP documentation or your organization's internal guidelines regarding benefit decisions to ensure compliance with the established processes.
  
  
  
  Contact Support:
  
  If you are unable to resolve the issue, consider reaching out to your SAP support team or system administrator for assistance. They may have additional insights or access to logs that can help diagnose the problem.
  
  
  
  Related Information:
  
  SAP Notes: Check for any relevant SAP Notes that may address this specific error or provide additional context.
  Training and Documentation: Ensure that users involved in creating benefit decisions are adequately trained and have access to the necessary documentation.
  System Configuration: Review the configuration settings in the Benefits Management module to ensure they align with your organization's policies and requirements.
  
  By following these steps, you should be able to identify the cause of the ICL584 error and take appropriate action to resolve it.