How To Fix THMHR_ADMIN017 - Hedge strategy must be the same for all hedging relationships

SAP Error Message - Details

• Message type: E = Error

• Message class: THMHR_ADMIN - Messages for managing hedge relationships

• Message number: 017

• Message text: Hedge strategy must be the same for all hedging relationships

What causes this issue?

The hedge strategy must be the same for all active hedging relationships
assigned to one interest risk hedge.

System Response

The hedging relationship cannot be created with the selected hedge
strategy.

How to fix this error?

Use the same hedge strategy for all hedging relationships with this
hedge. If a new strategy is required, you may dissolve or dedesignate
any active hedging relationships tied to this hedge, and then create the
new hedging relationship with the desired strategy.

Procedure for System Administrators

The system issues an error message and will not allow you to continue with this transaction until the error is resolved.

Error message extract from SAP system. Copyright SAP SE.

Smart SAP Assistant

• What is the cause and solution for SAP error message THMHR_ADMIN017 - Hedge strategy must be the same for all hedging relationships ?

  The SAP error message THMHR_ADMIN017 indicates that there is a discrepancy in the hedge strategies defined for different hedging relationships within a hedge management context. This error typically arises when you attempt to create or modify hedging relationships that have inconsistent hedge strategies.
  Cause:
  The primary cause of this error is that the hedging relationships you are trying to manage have different hedge strategies assigned to them. In SAP Treasury and Risk Management, all hedging relationships that are part of a single hedge strategy must share the same hedge strategy to ensure consistency in risk management and reporting.
  Solution:
  To resolve the THMHR_ADMIN017 error, you can follow these steps:
  
  
  Review Hedging Relationships: Check the hedging relationships involved in the transaction. Ensure that all relationships you are trying to manage have the same hedge strategy assigned.
  
  
  Modify Hedge Strategies: If you find that some hedging relationships have different strategies, you will need to either:
  
  Change the hedge strategy of the hedging relationships to match the others.
  Create a new hedge strategy that encompasses the relationships you want to manage together.
  
  
  
  Consistency Check: After making the necessary changes, perform a consistency check to ensure that all hedging relationships now have the same hedge strategy.
  
  
  Re-attempt the Transaction: Once the hedge strategies are aligned, re-attempt the transaction that triggered the error.
  
  
  Related Information:
  
  
  Hedge Strategy Definition: A hedge strategy in SAP is a framework that defines how financial instruments are used to hedge against risks. It includes parameters such as the type of risk being hedged, the instruments used, and the accounting treatment.
  
  
  Hedging Relationships: These are specific pairings of hedging instruments and the items being hedged. Each relationship must be clearly defined and consistent with the overall hedge strategy.
  
  
  SAP Documentation: For more detailed information, refer to the SAP Help Portal or the specific documentation related to SAP Treasury and Risk Management. This can provide insights into best practices for managing hedge strategies and hedging relationships.
  
  
  Consulting SAP Support: If the issue persists or if you need further assistance, consider reaching out to SAP Support or your internal SAP team for guidance tailored to your specific configuration and business processes.
  
  
  By ensuring that all hedging relationships share the same hedge strategy, you can effectively manage your hedging activities and avoid this error in the future.