How To Fix S#238 - Direct changes not permitted for assignments of generated profiles

SAP Error Message - Details

• Message type: E = Error

• Message class: S# -

• Message number: 238

• Message text: Direct changes not permitted for assignments of generated profiles

Self-Explanatory Message

Since SAP believes that this specific error message is 'self-explanatory,' no more information has been given.The majority of messages in the SAP system have a message text, however this is frequently insufficient to comprehend or resolve the problem.

To make things easier, more detailed information is frequently added to describe the issue, how to fix it, and the necessary steps or configuration modifications.

Unfortunately, there isn't any extra information in this error notice.

What else can you do?

First, use our AnswerBot below to get a possible cause and solution (requires a premium subscription).

Also, review the in-depth Common Questions & Answers listed below; you could discover a solution there or be able to connect with others who have faced similar challenges.

You can also try searching the SAP support portal (support.sap.com) but you need a special user ID to access it. It is possible that an SAP support note exists that provides additional details about the mistake or even steps for fixing it.

Smart SAP Assistant

• What is the cause and solution for SAP error message S#238 - Direct changes not permitted for assignments of generated profiles ?

  The SAP error message S#238, which states "Direct changes not permitted for assignments of generated profiles," typically occurs when there is an attempt to make direct changes to the assignments of generated profiles in the SAP system. This is a common issue in systems where profile management is tightly controlled, particularly in the context of authorization profiles.
  Cause:
  
  Generated Profiles: The error arises because the profile in question is a generated profile, which means it is created automatically by the system based on certain criteria or configurations. These profiles are not meant to be modified directly.
  Authorization Management: The system is designed to prevent direct changes to ensure integrity and consistency in authorization management. Changes should be made through the appropriate configuration transactions rather than directly in the assignments.
  
  Solution:
  To resolve this error, follow these steps:
  
  
  Use the Correct Transaction: Instead of trying to change the assignments directly, use the appropriate transaction to modify the underlying configuration that generates the profile. This could involve:
  
  PFCG (Profile Generator): If you are working with roles and authorizations, use transaction PFCG to manage roles and their associated profiles.
  SU01 (User Maintenance): If you need to assign or change user authorizations, use SU01 to manage user profiles and roles.
  
  
  
  Modify the Role: If you need to change the authorizations or assignments, do so by modifying the role associated with the generated profile. After making the necessary changes, regenerate the profile to reflect the updates.
  
  
  Check for Customizations: If there are customizations or enhancements in your SAP system that affect profile generation, ensure that they are correctly configured to allow for the necessary changes.
  
  
  Consult Documentation: Review SAP documentation or notes related to authorization management and profile generation for any specific guidelines or best practices.
  
  
  Related Information:
  
  Profile Management: Understanding how SAP handles profiles and authorizations is crucial. Profiles are collections of authorizations that define what users can do in the system.
  Role-Based Access Control (RBAC): Familiarize yourself with RBAC concepts in SAP, as they are fundamental to managing user access and security.
  SAP Notes: Check SAP Notes for any updates or patches related to this error message, as SAP frequently releases notes that address known issues or provide additional guidance.
  
  By following these steps and understanding the underlying principles of SAP's authorization management, you should be able to resolve the S#238 error effectively.